Another Future Reef

MV John F. Kennedy

MV John F. Kennedy is the last remaining Kennedy-class ferry, formerly operated for the Staten Island Ferry in New York City, New York, United States. It was built by the Levingston Shipbuilding Company between 1963 and 1965 for the Department of Marine and Aviation. The John F. Kennedy operated until 2021, and she was subsequently sold to Paul Italia, Ron Castellano, Colin Jost, and Pete Davidson. As of 2025, restoration of the John F. Kennedy had not yet started.

History

Built by the Levingston Shipbuilding Company between 1963 and 1965 for the Department of Marine and Aviation, the John F. Kennedy was delivered May 14, 1965. The vessel is 277 feet long with a beam of 69 feet, 2109 tons.

John F. Kennedy was named for the 35th President of the United States. She entered service in 1965 alongside her two sister ships, the MV American Legion and the MV The Gov. Herbert H. Lehman. While American Legion was retired in 2006 as the newer Molinari-class ferries entered service, and The Gov. Herbert H. Lehman was decommissioned the following year, John F. Kennedy remained in service as a favorite of both passengers and ferry operators, mainly running "as needed" on weekday schedules (when four of the six boats are needed for service). Captains considered her to be the most reliable vessel in the fleet, and riders preferred her abundant open-air deck space.

Retirement

John F. Kennedy was retired from service in August 2021, to be replaced by the recently completed MV Michael H. Ollis, the lead ship of a new trio of ferries, collectively known as the Ollis-class. The design of this new class is heavily influenced by John F. Kennedy, featuring her distinctive outdoor promenades and extended foredecks.

Following her retirement, Kennedy was moored at St. George Terminal to await her fate. By January 16, 2022, New York City was attempting to sell the vessel at auction for $125,000, after an earlier attempt to sell the vessel at $250,000 garnered no bids. The auction concluded on January 19, 2022, with the ferry sold "as is" and "where is" to Paul Italia, Ron Castellano, and Saturday Night Live comedians Colin Jost and Pete Davidson for a final selling price of $280,100. The new owners planned on converting the ferry into an entertainment venue at the cost of $34 million as of 2024. In April 2022, Kennedy was towed to a shipyard in New Brighton, Staten Island, since her final location remained undecided. Castellano said in early 2024 that he was continuing to revise the plans for Kennedy's renovation.

The first (and only) event held on the vessel, in September 2024, was a fashion show for Tommy Hilfiger's spring 2025 collection; this was the first time she had been towed away from the shipyard since 2022. Two years after Jost and Davidson's acquisition, the renovation of John F. Kennedy had still not started, and both men had expressed regret over acquiring the vessel; Jost's wife Scarlett Johansson had tried to get her husband to sell Kennedy. The company that had towed Kennedy to the shipyard had sued Jost and Davidson for non-payment of towing fees. The New York Times wrote that the vessel would require extensive modifications before being used as an entertainment venue, and that even scrapping her would likely not be cost-effective. Jost and Davidson tried to sell Kennedy (a move parodied in a May 2025 episode of Saturday Night Live) but later withdrew their offer.

-- Wikipedia

At least they can laugh about it

The Kennedy has two non-functioning engines (out of four) and is forbidden to move under its own power. The vessel will also require asbestos "abatement" before any kind of re-use. The planned renovations total $34 million, and in the current economy, its failure as an "entertainment venue" is a forgone conclusion. It would also have to pass multiple inspections, from the fire department to the Coast Guard. Good luck with that.

The vessel sits at a dock on the north shore of Staten Island, accruing dockage and insurance costs. If a boat is "a hole in the water that you try to fill with money", then the Kennedy is a really big hole. The nearest breaker's yard that could handle a vessel like this is in Brownsville Texas. The cost of towing it there would probably far exceed the scrap value of the metal, currently $200-$400/ton, minus the cost of drydocking and breaking-up the vessel. No matter how you look at it, the Kennedy is already underwater.

Saturday Night Live star Colin Jost called buying a decommissioned Staten Island ferry "absolutely the dumbest and least thought-through purchase I’ve ever made in my life."

" ... I guess ... if you have the space for it ... "
She is a very understanding wife.

Donating the vessel for an artificial reef would at least be a tax write-off. Copper, brass, and bronze could be recovered, and items like benches could be sold as souvenirs. Asbestos is not a problem underwater. Pete and Colin could each have a propeller for their front yard.

The Kennedy is fairly large for an artificial reef, specifically, tall. There are two reef sites in the region that are deep enough to accommodate the vessel without chopping it down to a giant bathtub: the 12-Mile Reef in New York and the Shark River Reef in New Jersey. In terms of accessibility, Shark River is the better choice.

Jost and Davidson are both multi-millionaires, and Scarlett Johansson is the highest-paid actress in Hollywood, so don't lose any sleep worrying about their finances. Writing-off this mistake is peanuts for them, and they have probably recouped the cost already making jokes about it. If it rusts at the dock long enough, sooner or later it will sink (hurricane?) and then the EPA is going to take an interest, and they won't be able to joke about it any more.


Comments on Another Future Reef

Questions or Inquiries?

Just want to say Hello? Sign the .

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Click image to replace if unable to read.

Enter the digits from the image above, except for the last one:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.